A decision journal is a record of important decisions written at the time you make them: the options you had, what you expect to happen, how sure you are and how you feel. A few months later you read the entry and judge the thinking, not only the result. That matters because once you know how things turned out, memory quietly edits what you knew and expected. Below is a template you can copy, one complete example about a job offer, a review schedule for three and twelve months, and what to look for when you reread.
What is a decision journal?
A decision journal is a short entry for each choice that matters, written before you know how it turns out. It records the decision, the options, the facts and guesses behind it, your prediction, how confident you are and your mood. Later you come back to it and compare.
It is different from writing your way to a decision. If you are still stuck choosing, journaling through a difficult decision helps you get there. The decision journal starts at the moment you choose, and it pays off months later, when you review.
Why write decisions down at the time?
Once you know the outcome, you cannot clearly remember what you thought before. Psychologists call this hindsight bias.
In a 1975 study, Baruch Fischhoff gave people accounts of historical events. Those who were told how an event ended rated that ending as more likely than people who were not told, and they kept doing so even when asked to answer as if they had not been told.
In another 1975 study, Fischhoff and Ruth Beyth asked students to estimate the chances of possible outcomes of President Nixon's 1972 trips to China and the Soviet Union before he went. Asked later to recall their estimates, many remembered giving higher odds to the events that had actually happened.
So a choice that went well starts to look obviously right, and one that went badly looks obviously foolish. A dated entry is the one version of your thinking that hindsight cannot edit.
What should a decision journal template include?
Ten fields fit on one page or one screen. Fill them in on the day you decide, ideally before you tell anyone, while the reasons are still only yours.
| Field | What to write | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Date and decision | One sentence naming the choice you made | 12 May: I am accepting the offer from the smaller company |
| Options | Every option you considered, including doing nothing | Accept, stay, or ask my manager for a raise first |
| What I know | Facts you have checked | About 15% more pay, a 50 minute commute each way |
| What I am guessing | Things you believe but have not confirmed | That the team lead I met will stay |
| What I expect | Specific outcomes, each with a time frame | Leading a project by November |
| How sure I am | A percentage for each main prediction | 70% that I am glad I moved, a year from now |
| What would prove me wrong | Signs that it was a poor call | No real project of my own after six months |
| How I feel | Mood, energy, sleep, anything pushing you | Excited, guilty about my team, slept badly |
| Who I talked to | Whose advice you took or went against | My partner was for it, my mentor against |
| Review dates | When you will reread the entry | 12 August, and 12 May next year |
What does a filled-in decision journal entry look like?
Here is the job offer entry written out in full. It takes about a page.
The most useful line is the one about wanting to prove something. Lines like that are uncomfortable to write and the most valuable to read later, because they show what was pushing you that you would not say out loud.
- Decision, 12 May: I am accepting the offer from the smaller company and will hand in my notice on Monday.
- Options: accept, stay where I am, or use the offer to ask my manager for a raise. I ruled out the raise because I would still be bored by summer.
- What I know: about 15% more pay, a 50 minute commute each way instead of 20, a team of eight instead of forty, a one month notice period.
- What I am guessing: that the team lead I met will stay at least a year, that the company's funding is stable, and that I can cope with the longer commute.
- What I expect: I will be leading the onboarding project by November. The first three months will feel harder than my current job. I will miss two people from my current team.
- How sure I am: 70% that a year from now I will be glad I moved, and 50% that I will be leading a project by November.
- What would prove me wrong: no real project of my own after six months, or the commute leaving me too tired to see friends during the week.
- How I feel: excited, a bit guilty about leaving mid-project, tired. I slept badly for three nights while deciding, and I notice part of me wants this to prove something to my current manager.
- Who I talked to: my partner was for it, and my mentor thought I should wait a year. I went against my mentor because this kind of role may not be open in a year.
- Review: 12 August, then 12 May next year.
When should you review a decision journal?
Put the review dates in your calendar on the day you write the entry. Reviews without a date tend not to happen.
Three months is long enough for early results and short enough that you still remember deciding. Twelve months shows how it played out. Some decisions need their own clock: a hire might be judged after six months, a move to a new city after a full year of seasons.
| When | What to check |
|---|---|
| After 1 week (optional) | How you feel now compared with the day you decided |
| After 3 months | Early results against what you expected, and which guesses turned out true |
| After 12 months | The main prediction, your confidence number, and what you would decide now with only what you knew then |
| When the outcome is clear | A closing note on what you learned, then the entry is done |
What should you look for when you review a decision?
Judge the decision and the outcome separately. A careful decision can turn out badly through bad luck, and a careless one can turn out well. Your entry is what lets you tell which is which.
Then answer a few questions in a short note under the original entry:
- Was my confidence about right? Over many entries, roughly seven in ten of your 70% predictions should come true.
- What did I miss that I could have known at the time?
- Which guess was wrong, and could I have checked it before deciding?
- Did my mood on the day push the decision one way?
- With the same information, would I make the same choice again?
| Your process | Good outcome | Bad outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Careful | Earned. Note what you did right so you can repeat it. | Bad luck. Do not throw out a sound method because of one result. |
| Careless | Lucky. The risky box, because it teaches the wrong lesson. | A clear lesson. Find the step you skipped. |
Which decisions are worth logging?
Log decisions that are expensive, hard to undo or likely to come up again. If you log everything, you will stop. A handful a year in your personal life is plenty.
Work choices are often the ones you will be asked to explain later, so a work journal is a natural home for them. Skip anything you could undo tomorrow at little cost, such as most purchases and plans for the weekend.
- Taking or leaving a job
- Moving house or city
- Large purchases, such as a car
- Taking on a big commitment of time, such as a course or a volunteer role
- Hiring someone or choosing a supplier at work
- Any choice you have gone back and forth on for more than a week
What if you keep reopening a decision you already made?
Read the entry before you argue with yourself again. Usually you knew more on the day than you remember, and the doubt is about something you already weighed.
If the doubts keep coming back anyway, journaling for decisions you keep circling back to looks at what tends to sit underneath that loop. Write down the new fact, if there is one. If there is none, the decision stands until the review date.
Should you keep a decision journal on paper or in an app?
Paper works if every entry goes in one notebook and the review dates also go in your calendar. A notes app or a document works too, with one note per decision and the date in the title so you can find it.
In Reflectize, an AI journal, you can type or dictate the entry. Its assistant Refy can suggest saving the review date as an event in the calendar, which you confirm, and search across your journal finds the entry when that day comes.
What mistakes make a decision journal useless?
Most decision journals fail in the same few ways:
- Writing the entry after you already know how it went.
- Vague predictions such as it will work out, which nobody can check.
- No confidence number, so you cannot tell whether you were overconfident.
- Judging only by the outcome at the review.
- Never reviewing. Without the reread, it is only a diary.
- Logging so many small choices that the habit falls apart.
Sources
- Hindsight is not equal to foresight: The effect of outcome knowledge on judgment under uncertaintyJournal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance (Fischhoff, 1975)
- I knew it would happen: Remembered probabilities of once-future thingsOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance (Fischhoff and Beyth, 1975)
This piece is part of weekly reviews and planning. Reflection is most useful when it points at something. These reads cover weekly and monthly reviews, keeping goals honest, and thinking through a decision on paper.